top of page

How your first financial closing in the U.S. differs from France

7 days ago
8 min read
Accounting closing of a US subsidiary using Pennylane in France, QuickBooks in the United States, and US tax forms

Your U.S. subsidiary is reaching the end of its first year in business. Sales have been recorded in QuickBooks, payroll has been processed, expenses have been paid, and several transfers may already have moved between France and the United States. Now comes the first year-end close.


For a French business owner, some of the basics will feel familiar: reconciling bank accounts, checking invoices, making sure revenue and expenses are recorded in the right period, and reviewing receivables and payables.


But the U.S. framework is different. You will not find exactly the same chart of accounts, filing calendar, or sequence between financial statements, tax filings, and administrative requirements.


And when the U.S. company is owned by a French parent company, there is another important layer: you also need to be able to clearly explain the transactions between the two entities.


Key takeaways:

  • A U.S. year-end close is not simply a U.S. version of the French closing process. Accounting, tax filings, and administrative requirements follow a different structure.

  • The profit shown in QuickBooks is not necessarily the taxable income used to calculate corporate income tax.

  • For a U.S. subsidiary owned by a French company, intercompany transactions must be tracked carefully: loans, services, interest, reimbursements, purchases, and sales between the two entities.

  • Certain transactions with the French parent company may have to be reported on Form 5472, with significant penalties for non-compliance.

  • The federal tax return is not always the only filing required. Depending on where the company operates, state-level filings may also apply.

  • Once the U.S. books are closed, the figures still need to be integrated into the French group’s reporting so management can maintain a consistent view of the business.


Do not look for an exact U.S. equivalent of a French year-end close


In France, the closing process leads to annual financial statements prepared within a highly structured accounting framework: balance sheet, income statement, notes where required, followed by shareholder approval and, depending on the company, filing with the relevant registry.


In the United States, the process is less standardized. For a typical privately held subsidiary, the year-end close is primarily about finalizing the company’s books and preparing its tax filings. SEC financial reporting requirements mainly apply to companies subject to U.S. public-market reporting rules, not automatically to a privately held SME simply because it has a U.S. entity.


Your U.S. subsidiary still needs accurate and reliable books, of course. But trying to reproduce the French closing process step by step usually creates more confusion than clarity.



The U.S. chart of accounts does not work like the French "Plan comptable général"


In France, the Plan comptable général (General Accounting Plan) provides a common and highly structured accounting framework.


In the United States, the IRS does not impose a standardized chart of accounts comparable to the French PCG. A business can organize its accounting system around its own operations, provided it properly tracks income, expenses, and the information required for tax reporting.


That is one reason why two U.S. companies using QuickBooks can have very different charts of accounts.


For a U.S. subsidiary belonging to a French group, however, that flexibility needs to be managed carefully. The U.S. chart of accounts must support the local business while also allowing the figures to be mapped back to the French parent company’s reporting structure.


For example, the same type of expense may be categorized differently in QuickBooks in the U.S. and in Pennylane in France. For group reporting, each account therefore needs to be mapped into a common reporting structure.


That mapping is what allows management to compare France and U.S. performance using the same KPIs.




Before preparing the tax return, you need to make sure the books are accurate


Accounting closing of a US subsidiary using Pennylane in France, QuickBooks in the United States, and US tax forms

The first step remains very operational. At year-end, you need to review bank accounts and credit cards, outstanding customer invoices, vendor bills, payroll, fixed assets, inventory where applicable, and any amounts due between the French parent company and the U.S. subsidiary.


You also need to make sure revenue and expenses are recorded in the correct accounting period.

Take a simple example. Your U.S. subsidiary receives a $20,000 invoice in January for services performed in December. Depending on the accounting method used, that expense may need to be recorded in the year that just ended, even though payment will take place later.


The underlying principle will sound familiar to a French business owner, but the applicable U.S. rules depend in part on the accounting method used by the company.


In the U.S., a business may in some cases use the cash method or the accrual method. Certain companies are required to use the accrual method depending on factors such as size or business activity. The accounting method should be defined from the start and applied consistently.



Your U.S. fiscal year does not necessarily have to end on December 31


A U.S. corporation can operate on a calendar year, from January 1 through December 31, but in some cases it can also adopt a different fiscal year.


And, for a French group, this is worth considering when the subsidiary is created.

If the French parent closes on December 31 while the U.S. subsidiary closes on another date, group reporting can become more complicated. Management may need to adjust reporting periods before comparing or consolidating the figures.


Where appropriate, aligning closing dates can make group reporting significantly easier.


It is also necessary to distinguish between the accounting year-end and the tax filing deadline. For a calendar-year C Corporation, Form 1120 is generally due on the 15th day of the fourth month after year-end, which is typically April 15. An extension can be requested, but extending the filing deadline does not necessarily extend the deadline for paying the tax due.



The profit shown in QuickBooks is not necessarily your taxable income


This is another important point during the first year-end close. Your income statement may show a $200,000 profit. That does not automatically mean federal corporate income tax will be calculated directly on that $200,000. Some expenses or income items may receive different treatment for tax purposes than they do for accounting purposes.


The U.S. corporate tax return therefore starts with the company’s accounting records and, where necessary, applies adjustments to arrive at taxable income.


For certain companies, Form 1120 includes a reconciliation between book income and taxable income.


For a business owner, the key point is simple: the year-end profit shown in QuickBooks does not, by itself, tell you exactly how much tax the company will owe.


The closing process is what allows the books to be finalized and the required tax adjustments to be made.



For a French parent company, France-US transactions become a major year-end issue


This is often where the first close of a French subsidiary in the United States becomes more specific.


Throughout the year, a number of transactions may have taken place between the two entities: funding from the French parent, intercompany loans, interest, management or support services, purchases or sales between the companies, and expense reimbursements...


Accounting closing of a US subsidiary using Pennylane in France, QuickBooks in the United States, and US tax forms

At year-end, both sets of books need to agree. If the French parent records a €100,000 receivable from the U.S. subsidiary, the U.S. books should show the corresponding payable in dollars, taking into account the exchange-rate methodology used.


Intercompany services must also be recorded consistently on both sides, with matching amounts and periods. Differences left unresolved for several months can make group reporting and tax preparation unnecessarily difficult.


This is particularly important because certain transactions between the U.S. subsidiary and its French parent company must be reported to the IRS.



Form 5472: an obligation you do not want to discover after year-end


When a U.S. corporation is at least 25% foreign-owned, certain transactions with its foreign shareholder or other related parties may have to be reported on Form 5472. For a U.S. subsidiary owned by a French company, this is therefore a common requirement.


Reportable transactions can include intercompany loans, interest, purchases or sales between related companies, and certain service transactions.


Form 5472 is generally filed together with the U.S. corporate income tax return. And this is not a minor compliance point: the IRS can impose an initial $25,000 penalty for failing to file a complete and accurate Form 5472 on time.


The best approach is to identify and track France–U.S. transactions throughout the year rather than trying to reconstruct them shortly before the filing deadline.


This is also why the way you fund your U.S. subsidiary (equity, intercompany loan, or advance) should be properly structured and recorded from the outset.




The federal tax return is only one part of the U.S. year-end process


You also need to look at the states in which the company operates. Requirements can vary significantly from one state to another. Depending on the situation, a company may have a federal filing with the IRS and, at the same time, income tax filings, franchise taxes, annual reports, or other obligations in one or more states.


A company incorporated in one state but carrying on significant business in another may have obligations in multiple jurisdictions.


The first year-end close is therefore also a good time to review whether the company’s growth during the year has created additional state-level obligations.


This ties directly into the concept of nexus: employees, offices, inventory, or the level of business conducted in a state can trigger obligations independently of the federal tax return.




For the French group, the U.S. close does not end with Form 1120


Once the U.S. books are finalized, the figures still need to be integrated into group reporting.

The French parent company may be using Pennylane while the U.S. subsidiary operates in QuickBooks. The two entities work in different currencies and within different accounting environments.


The group therefore needs a process to reconcile intercompany balances, convert figures into the group reporting currency, identify or eliminate intercompany transactions, and present the results using a common reporting structure.


Your U.S. subsidiary can have perfectly accurate local books and still be difficult to manage from France if this process has not been planned. The first year-end close is a good opportunity to establish a method that can then be reused every month or quarter. That makes the second year significantly easier.



Blendy supports your first U.S. year-end close on both sides of the Atlantic


A U.S. subsidiary should not operate as if it were completely disconnected from its French parent company.


Blendy, an international accounting firm based in Paris, Montreal and Miami, works with France–U.S. groups on both the local U.S. accounting and the connection with the French parent.


Blendy is an international chartered accountant, based in Paris, Miami and Montreal.

We can help:

  • organize the U.S. year-end close,

  • reconcile balances between the two companies,

  • identify intercompany transactions that need to be reported in the U.S., and

  • build a common reporting framework between QuickBooks and the French finance environment.


Because we understand both accounting environments, we can also explain the differences to management without expecting the business owner to become an expert in French and U.S. accounting rules.


The first close is an opportunity to establish a repeatable process: which accounts need to be monitored, how France–U.S. transactions should be recorded, when intercompany balances should be reconciled, and which information needs to flow back to the group.


The goal is to close the U.S. books without discovering at year-end that transactions should have been tracked months earlier.


Is your U.S. subsidiary approaching its first year-end close?


Blendy can help you prepare the U.S. accounts and integrate them into your France–U.S. group reporting.









Sources:



With Blendy, international CPA based in France, Canada and the USA, take advantage of digital accounting and tailor-made advice to accelerate your financial process and develop your business.


Pennylane, Dext, QuickBooks and Stripe certified, we support digital and IT companies, e-Commerce, SaaS in France and internationally.


bottom of page